donald willis
2020-08-25 17:49:37 UTC
John Corbett: No one said he saw a shooter (or rifle) in Dealey (amended)
I hate to confront you with facts but not one of them said they noticed
how wide open the window was. Brennan used the word "notice(d)" six times
in his testimony, none regarding how wide open the window was. Jackson,
Fischer, and Edwards used it once each, also not regarding how wide open
the window was.
Couch and Euins never used the word. None of these witnesses said they
noticed how wide open the window was. ("Don Willis' dilemma"
(alt.assassination.jfk 8/21/20) "Not one of them said they noticed how
wide open the window was."
Mr. Corbett's argument is that none of the witnesses named above used the
word "notice"... "regarding how wide open the window was". So "none of
these witnesses said they noticed how wide open the window was." Yes, they
had to use the word "notice". No synonyms, like "see", allowed. Professor
Corbett is strict. Using the Corbett Standard, Robert Jackson did NOT say
that he NOTICED a rifle: "I saw the rifle.... half the weapon I guess I
saw, and just as I looked at it, it was drawn fairly slowly back into the
building." (v2p159) Oops! He forgot to say "noticed". Jackson only "saw"
and "looked". So, using the Corbett Standard, he did not say that he
NOTICED a rifle. This will be news to anyone who has studied the JFK
assassination. Witness Howard Brennan testified that "I saw this one man
on the sixth floor ". (v3p193.) His 11/22/63 affidavit would be similarly
disqualified using the Corbett Standard: "I saw a man in this window.... I
then saw this man.... I was looking at this man...."
Nor, according to the Corbett Standard, did Robert Edwards say that he
NOTICED a man: "I saw a man at the window.... There was a stack of boxes
around him, I could see." Mr. Corbett would insist that Edwards did not
say that he NOTICED either man nor boxes. Nor did witness Ronald Fischer
say that he NOTICED anyone: "I watched the man... all the time I watched
him...." (v6p193) Nor did witness Amos Euins: "I saw a man in a window
with a gun." (11/22/63 affidavit)
According to the Encarta College Dictionary, "see" is a synonym for
"notice".... According to Prof. Corbett, it isn't. Anthony Marsh would be
proud of Mr. Corbett. The latter has single-handedly eliminated witnesses
to the depository shooter in Dealey, and Marsh has always said not to
trust witnesses anyway, though Corbett may be going too far even for him.
According to the Corbett Standard, no one said that he NOTICED a suspect
in Dealey, let alone a shooter or a rifle.
Corbett serves notice....
dcw
Jackson, Brennan, Fischer, Edwards, Couch, and Euins all said that they
noticed how wide the window was open. None of them (except Couch) said that they couldn't remember. They noticed, despite your incredulity.
To which John Corbett replied:noticed how wide the window was open. None of them (except Couch) said that they couldn't remember. They noticed, despite your incredulity.
I hate to confront you with facts but not one of them said they noticed
how wide open the window was. Brennan used the word "notice(d)" six times
in his testimony, none regarding how wide open the window was. Jackson,
Fischer, and Edwards used it once each, also not regarding how wide open
the window was.
Couch and Euins never used the word. None of these witnesses said they
noticed how wide open the window was. ("Don Willis' dilemma"
(alt.assassination.jfk 8/21/20) "Not one of them said they noticed how
wide open the window was."
Mr. Corbett's argument is that none of the witnesses named above used the
word "notice"... "regarding how wide open the window was". So "none of
these witnesses said they noticed how wide open the window was." Yes, they
had to use the word "notice". No synonyms, like "see", allowed. Professor
Corbett is strict. Using the Corbett Standard, Robert Jackson did NOT say
that he NOTICED a rifle: "I saw the rifle.... half the weapon I guess I
saw, and just as I looked at it, it was drawn fairly slowly back into the
building." (v2p159) Oops! He forgot to say "noticed". Jackson only "saw"
and "looked". So, using the Corbett Standard, he did not say that he
NOTICED a rifle. This will be news to anyone who has studied the JFK
assassination. Witness Howard Brennan testified that "I saw this one man
on the sixth floor ". (v3p193.) His 11/22/63 affidavit would be similarly
disqualified using the Corbett Standard: "I saw a man in this window.... I
then saw this man.... I was looking at this man...."
Nor, according to the Corbett Standard, did Robert Edwards say that he
NOTICED a man: "I saw a man at the window.... There was a stack of boxes
around him, I could see." Mr. Corbett would insist that Edwards did not
say that he NOTICED either man nor boxes. Nor did witness Ronald Fischer
say that he NOTICED anyone: "I watched the man... all the time I watched
him...." (v6p193) Nor did witness Amos Euins: "I saw a man in a window
with a gun." (11/22/63 affidavit)
According to the Encarta College Dictionary, "see" is a synonym for
"notice".... According to Prof. Corbett, it isn't. Anthony Marsh would be
proud of Mr. Corbett. The latter has single-handedly eliminated witnesses
to the depository shooter in Dealey, and Marsh has always said not to
trust witnesses anyway, though Corbett may be going too far even for him.
According to the Corbett Standard, no one said that he NOTICED a suspect
in Dealey, let alone a shooter or a rifle.
Corbett serves notice....
dcw