Discussion:
Testimony Of James Patrick Hosty, Jr.
(too old to reply)
claviger
2018-05-06 00:34:30 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
The Warren Commission
Testimony Of James Patrick Hosty, Jr.
http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/russ/testimony/hosty.htm


Interview - James P. Hosty
http://www.nleomf.org/assets/pdfs/nlem/oral-histories/FBI_Hosty_interview.pdf

Mar 8, 2006 - If they had bothered to ask me which they didn't, I could
have told them I was forbidden to interview Oswald because he was a
contact case. As you all know, .... And that Marina later confided to Ruth
Paine, who wasn't a relative, but was the ... Paine's, that was very far
from work from the book depository,. H:.


James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm

Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-07 00:35:18 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
The Warren Commission
Testimony Of James Patrick Hosty, Jr.
http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/russ/testimony/hosty.htm
Interview - James P. Hosty
http://www.nleomf.org/assets/pdfs/nlem/oral-histories/FBI_Hosty_interview.pdf
Mar 8, 2006 - If they had bothered to ask me which they didn't, I could
have told them I was forbidden to interview Oswald because he was a
contact case. As you all know, .... And that Marina later confided to Ruth
Paine, who wasn't a relative, but was the ... Paine's, that was very far
from work from the book depository,. H:.
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
claviger
2018-05-12 03:07:04 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
Cover up what exactly?
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-14 00:09:20 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
Cover up what exactly?
Incompetence.

You think the cover-up was to hide the accident.


That has nothing to do with Oswald's threatening note.
claviger
2018-05-15 02:57:55 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
Cover up what exactly?
Incompetence.
In what way?
Post by Anthony Marsh
You think the cover-up was to hide the accident.
Yes.
Post by Anthony Marsh
That has nothing to do with Oswald's threatening note.
Yes, and your point is?
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-17 02:00:53 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
Cover up what exactly?
Incompetence.
In what way?
Post by Anthony Marsh
You think the cover-up was to hide the accident.
Yes.
Post by Anthony Marsh
That has nothing to do with Oswald's threatening note.
Yes, and your point is?
Which CYA do you think was the primary motivation for the cover-up?
Hosty not tracking down Oswald or the SS covering up an accidental shot
by one of its agents? And also the Kennedy aides only a foot away?
claviger
2018-05-18 00:11:32 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
Cover up what exactly?
Incompetence.
In what way?
Post by Anthony Marsh
You think the cover-up was to hide the accident.
Yes.
Post by Anthony Marsh
That has nothing to do with Oswald's threatening note.
Yes, and your point is?
Which CYA do you think was the primary motivation for the cover-up?
Hosty not tracking down Oswald or the SS covering up an accidental shot
by one of its agents? And also the Kennedy aides only a foot away?
Good questions.

Arresting LHO for a dangerous threat of violence in writing to blow
up the Dallas FBI Office might have saved the President. LHO could
still be in jail during the Parade. TSBD management would find out
and LHO suspended if not terminated, and not have access to the
6th floor window.

I believe an accidental weapon discharge was the primary cause for
the cover-up ordered by Attorney General Robert Kennedy. He did
the right thing at the time knowing how demoralizing it would be to
the Secret Service and to the Nation. It would be very demoralizing
to the Kennedy family if as I suspect, SSA Hickey was a loyal cousin
to the President. This would also explain the curious situation why
so much of the evidence was controlled by the SS that should have
been available to the FBI and public research community.

If the FBI figured out what happened could they be trusted to keep
the secret? I'm convinced LBJ somehow found out and ordered the
AR15 deleted from the list of approved weapons allowed the SSA to
carry in future parades.

Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.

When Howard Donahue accidentally figured out what happened
he decided to maintain silence too, until reading about numerous
conspiracy theories he knew were wrong. He was appalled by the
pervasive ignorance about firearms and bullet wounds. Disgusted
by this misinformation masquerading as facts, he finally wrote an
article for the Baltimore Sun.

Eventually he was convinced to allow a book to be written strictly as
a scientific analysis without the conspiracy theories. I read the book
and was impressed by the classic Scientific Method approach which
set it apart from all other conspiracy books, until a curious Detective
in Australia read the book. He too was impressed by the science and
spent four years doing his own research and he eventually confirmed
the same ballistic analysis with his own book.



Mortal Error
Author: Bonar Menninger 1992

JFK, The Smoking Gun
Author: Colin McLaren 2013
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-19 01:26:39 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
James P. Hosty - Spartacus Educational
http://spartacus-educational.com/JFKhosty.htm
Hosty visited the home of Ruth Paine to discover where Oswald was living.
He spoke to both Paine and Marina Oswald about Oswald. When Oswald heard
about the visit he went to the FBI office in Dallas. When told that Hosty
was at lunch Oswald left him a message in an envelope. The contents of the
envelope has ...
Can you spell cover-up? Do you know what CYA means?
Cover up what exactly?
Incompetence.
In what way?
Post by Anthony Marsh
You think the cover-up was to hide the accident.
Yes.
Post by Anthony Marsh
That has nothing to do with Oswald's threatening note.
Yes, and your point is?
Which CYA do you think was the primary motivation for the cover-up?
Hosty not tracking down Oswald or the SS covering up an accidental shot
by one of its agents? And also the Kennedy aides only a foot away?
Good questions.
Arresting LHO for a dangerous threat of violence in writing to blow
up the Dallas FBI Office might have saved the President. LHO could
still be in jail during the Parade. TSBD management would find out
and LHO suspended if not terminated, and not have access to the
6th floor window.
I believe an accidental weapon discharge was the primary cause for
the cover-up ordered by Attorney General Robert Kennedy. He did
Physically impossible. And Bobby is not the one who ordered the
cover-up. LBJ ordered the cover-up because he KNEW it was a conspiracy.
Bobby and LBJ hated each other.
Post by claviger
the right thing at the time knowing how demoralizing it would be to
the Secret Service and to the Nation. It would be very demoralizing
to the Kennedy family if as I suspect, SSA Hickey was a loyal cousin
to the President. This would also explain the curious situation why
What does that have to do with anything? It was physically imcpossible.
Post by claviger
so much of the evidence was controlled by the SS that should have
been available to the FBI and public research community.
The FBI investigated beyond what the SS did.
Post by claviger
If the FBI figured out what happened could they be trusted to keep
the secret? I'm convinced LBJ somehow found out and ordered the
AR15 deleted from the list of approved weapons allowed the SSA to
carry in future parades.
Differeent problem. Unrelated.
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Post by claviger
When Howard Donahue accidentally figured out what happened
he decided to maintain silence too, until reading about numerous
You're not trying hard enough. Why didn't they kill him too?
And who was supposed to kill Hickey?
Post by claviger
conspiracy theories he knew were wrong. He was appalled by the
pervasive ignorance about firearms and bullet wounds. Disgusted
by this misinformation masquerading as facts, he finally wrote an
article for the Baltimore Sun.
How about HIS ignorance of the difference between hardened lead and
unhardened lead?
Post by claviger
Eventually he was convinced to allow a book to be written strictly as
a scientific analysis without the conspiracy theories. I read the book
and was impressed by the classic Scientific Method approach which
set it apart from all other conspiracy books, until a curious Detective
in Australia read the book. He too was impressed by the science and
spent four years doing his own research and he eventually confirmed
the same ballistic analysis with his own book.
Mortal Error
Author: Bonar Menninger 1992
JFK, The Smoking Gun
Author: Colin McLaren 2013
Garbage
claviger
2018-05-20 01:34:30 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
I believe an accidental weapon discharge was the primary cause for
the cover-up ordered by Attorney General Robert Kennedy.
Physically impossible.
You have been proved wrong about this before, and yet continue to
recycle your childish propaganda.
Post by Anthony Marsh
And Bobby is not the one who ordered the cover-up. LBJ ordered the
cover-up because he KNEW it was a conspiracy. Bobby and LBJ hated
each other.
Bobby is the only one who could order a cover-up that loyal JFK staff
would pay attention to.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
the right thing at the time knowing how demoralizing it would be to
the Secret Service and to the Nation. It would be very demoralizing
to the Kennedy family if as I suspect, SSA Hickey was a loyal cousin
to the President. This would also explain the curious situation why
What does that have to do with anything? It was physically imcpossible.
You are easily proved wrong by photographs of people in the Limousine.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
so much of the evidence was controlled by the SS that should have
been available to the FBI and public research community.
The FBI investigated beyond what the SS did.
The SSA controlled much of the evidence.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
If the FBI figured out what happened could they be trusted to keep
the secret? I'm convinced LBJ somehow found out and ordered the
AR15 deleted from the list of approved weapons allowed the SSA to
carry in future parades.
Differeent problem. Unrelated.
How so?
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Assassination yes, accidental mishap no.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
When Howard Donahue accidentally figured out what happened
he decided to maintain silence too, until reading about numerous
You're not trying hard enough. Why didn't they kill him too?
And who was supposed to kill Hickey?
Who is they? Do you mean the Kennedy family?
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
conspiracy theories he knew were wrong. He was appalled by the
pervasive ignorance about firearms and bullet wounds. Disgusted
by this misinformation masquerading as facts, he finally wrote an
article for the Baltimore Sun.
How about HIS ignorance of the difference between hardened lead
and unhardened lead?
Donahue was a real firearms expert, not a pretender like you.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Eventually he was convinced to allow a book to be written strictly as
a scientific analysis without the conspiracy theories. I read the book
and was impressed by the classic Scientific Method approach which
set it apart from all other conspiracy books, until a curious Detective
in Australia read the book. He too was impressed by the science and
spent four years doing his own research and he eventually confirmed
the same ballistic analysis with his own book.
Mortal Error
Author: Bonar Menninger 1992
JFK, The Smoking Gun
Author: Colin McLaren 2013
Garbage
Two experts who corroborate actual ballistic science,
not the silly stuff you make up.
claviger
2018-05-21 01:55:32 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Assassination yes, accidental mishap no.
Assassination
Yes: It is ludicrous to think JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.

Accident
No: If the President was wounded by an accidental shot
by a bodyguard, not surprising they would follow orders
from RFK and keep quiet.
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-22 22:35:15 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Assassination yes, accidental mishap no.
Assassination
Yes: It is ludicrous to think JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Accident
No: If the President was wounded by an accidental shot
by a bodyguard, not surprising they would follow orders
from RFK and keep quiet.
No. Impossible. Within seconds? How would they know what to cover up? It
took months before the FBI told them to shut about the grassy knoll shot.
claviger
2018-05-23 20:26:49 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Assassination yes, accidental mishap no.
Assassination
Yes: It is ludicrous to think JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Accident
No: If the President was wounded by an accidental shot
by a bodyguard, not surprising they would follow orders
from RFK and keep quiet.
No. Impossible. Within seconds? How would they know what to cover up? It
took months before the FBI told them to shut about the grassy knoll shot.
This is very simple. Keep in mind the first loud sound they
heard was the close ricochet off the curb, from a first shot
miss. Next a loud second shot that wounded the President
and Governor. Then the two WH staffers heard a loud blast
right behind them that sounded much closer, as if it came
from the backseat. They may have instinctively turned just
enough to see a bodyguard was holding a rifle. Did the last
shot come from that rifle?

After arriving at the hospital they would call RFK first before
saying anything to anyone else. When he found out his own
cousin carried the rifle that day he then realized it was not an
assassination by the SSA. It must have been an accident, but
making that public would shock the world, and devastate the
Kennedy family. So the President's own brother made a tough
decision to keep it a secret forever. The reason why the USSS
became the guardians of all the medical evidence in this tragic
case.
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-24 22:05:10 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Assassination yes, accidental mishap no.
Assassination
Yes: It is ludicrous to think JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Accident
No: If the President was wounded by an accidental shot
by a bodyguard, not surprising they would follow orders
from RFK and keep quiet.
No. Impossible. Within seconds? How would they know what to cover up? It
took months before the FBI told them to shut about the grassy knoll shot.
This is very simple. Keep in mind the first loud sound they
heard was the close ricochet off the curb, from a first shot
miss. Next a loud second shot that wounded the President
and Governor. Then the two WH staffers heard a loud blast
right behind them that sounded much closer, as if it came
from the backseat. They may have instinctively turned just
enough to see a bodyguard was holding a rifle. Did the last
shot come from that rifle?
After arriving at the hospital they would call RFK first before
saying anything to anyone else. When he found out his own
cousin carried the rifle that day he then realized it was not an
assassination by the SSA. It must have been an accident, but
making that public would shock the world, and devastate the
Kennedy family. So the President's own brother made a tough
decision to keep it a secret forever. The reason why the USSS
became the guardians of all the medical evidence in this tragic
case.
Nonsense.

Anthony Marsh
2018-05-21 15:01:37 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
I believe an accidental weapon discharge was the primary cause for
the cover-up ordered by Attorney General Robert Kennedy.
Physically impossible.
You have been proved wrong about this before, and yet continue to
recycle your childish propaganda.
Post by Anthony Marsh
And Bobby is not the one who ordered the cover-up. LBJ ordered the
cover-up because he KNEW it was a conspiracy. Bobby and LBJ hated
each other.
Bobby is the only one who could order a cover-up that loyal JFK staff
would pay attention to.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
the right thing at the time knowing how demoralizing it would be to
the Secret Service and to the Nation. It would be very demoralizing
to the Kennedy family if as I suspect, SSA Hickey was a loyal cousin
to the President. This would also explain the curious situation why
What does that have to do with anything? It was physically imcpossible.
You are easily proved wrong by photographs of people in the Limousine.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
so much of the evidence was controlled by the SS that should have
been available to the FBI and public research community.
The FBI investigated beyond what the SS did.
The SSA controlled much of the evidence.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
If the FBI figured out what happened could they be trusted to keep
the secret? I'm convinced LBJ somehow found out and ordered the
AR15 deleted from the list of approved weapons allowed the SSA to
carry in future parades.
Differeent problem. Unrelated.
How so?
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Two Whitehouse aides were closest to the loud blast than other
passengers and would first notify Robert Kennedy before saying
anything to anyone else. It would make sense RFK ordered them
to maintain silence as a tragic family secret and never tell anyone.
It is ludicrous for you to think that JFK's cloest aides and friends
would help cover up his assassination.
Assassination yes, accidental mishap no.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
When Howard Donahue accidentally figured out what happened
he decided to maintain silence too, until reading about numerous
You're not trying hard enough. Why didn't they kill him too?
And who was supposed to kill Hickey?
Who is they? Do you mean the Kennedy family?
No, whoever YOU think the THEY are who covered up the accident. That is
NOT the Kennedy family.
Maybe you think it was the Secret Service.
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
conspiracy theories he knew were wrong. He was appalled by the
pervasive ignorance about firearms and bullet wounds. Disgusted
by this misinformation masquerading as facts, he finally wrote an
article for the Baltimore Sun.
How about HIS ignorance of the difference between hardened lead
and unhardened lead?
Donahue was a real firearms expert, not a pretender like you.
HE was just a pretender. I never pretended to be any expert.
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Eventually he was convinced to allow a book to be written strictly as
a scientific analysis without the conspiracy theories. I read the book
and was impressed by the classic Scientific Method approach which
set it apart from all other conspiracy books, until a curious Detective
in Australia read the book. He too was impressed by the science and
spent four years doing his own research and he eventually confirmed
the same ballistic analysis with his own book.
Mortal Error
Author: Bonar Menninger 1992
JFK, The Smoking Gun
Author: Colin McLaren 2013
Garbage
Two experts who corroborate actual ballistic science,
not the silly stuff you make up.
Not experts. Kooks.
claviger
2018-05-22 05:10:14 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Donahue was a real firearms expert, not a pretender like you.
HE was just a pretender.
Well he sure did a good job pretending since he outperformed every other
volunteer shooter in the 1967 CBS Field Test, then opened a gun sales and
repair store for several years. Donahue sold all kinds of rifles,
handguns, ammo and did repairs himself, also invented improvements on
certain rifles and shotguns. Due to his knowledge he was sought after as a
consultant by police departments and called to testify as an expert
witness in several different trials involving shooting incidents. He also
took classes in Ballistic Science taught by FBI Cortlandt Cunningham. Did
you ever do any of these things?
Post by Anthony Marsh
I never pretended to be any expert.
A good thing because obviously you're not.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Eventually he was convinced to allow a book to be written strictly as
a scientific analysis without the conspiracy theories. I read the book
and was impressed by the classic Scientific Method approach which
set it apart from all other conspiracy books, until a curious Detective
in Australia read the book. He too was impressed by the science and
spent four years doing his own research and he eventually confirmed
the same ballistic analysis with his own book.
Mortal Error
Author: Bonar Menninger 1992
JFK, The Smoking Gun
Author: Colin McLaren 2013
Garbage
Two experts who corroborate actual ballistic science,
not the silly stuff you make up.
Not experts. Kooks.
Only a kook would call two experienced weapons experts a kook.
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-23 15:18:08 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Donahue was a real firearms expert, not a pretender like you.
HE was just a pretender.
Well he sure did a good job pretending since he outperformed every other
volunteer shooter in the 1967 CBS Field Test, then opened a gun sales and
Being a good shot does not qualify him as a firearms expert.
He didn't even understand the difference between unhardened lead and
hardened lead.
Post by claviger
repair store for several years. Donahue sold all kinds of rifles,
handguns, ammo and did repairs himself, also invented improvements on
certain rifles and shotguns. Due to his knowledge he was sought after as a
Not impressed.
The guys at the local gun store wanted to impress me, but they didn't
even know that SMI bullets are NOT STEEL JACKETED. It took a real
expert, me, to use a magnet to prove that they were only COPPER jacketed.
Post by claviger
consultant by police departments and called to testify as an expert
witness in several different trials involving shooting incidents. He also
took classes in Ballistic Science taught by FBI Cortlandt Cunningham. Did
you ever do any of these things?
No, not impressed by your phony Argument by Authority.
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
I never pretended to be any expert.
A good thing because obviously you're not.
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Post by Anthony Marsh
Post by claviger
Eventually he was convinced to allow a book to be written strictly as
a scientific analysis without the conspiracy theories. I read the book
and was impressed by the classic Scientific Method approach which
set it apart from all other conspiracy books, until a curious Detective
in Australia read the book. He too was impressed by the science and
spent four years doing his own research and he eventually confirmed
the same ballistic analysis with his own book.
Mortal Error
Author: Bonar Menninger 1992
JFK, The Smoking Gun
Author: Colin McLaren 2013
Garbage
Two experts who corroborate actual ballistic science,
not the silly stuff you make up.
Not experts. Kooks.
Only a kook would call two experienced weapons experts a kook.
How many times are you going to repeat this meaningless kook story?
claviger
2018-05-19 01:47:23 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by claviger
When Howard Donahue accidentally figured out what happened
he decided to maintain silence too, until reading about numerous
conspiracy theories he knew were wrong. He was appalled by the
pervasive ignorance about firearms and bullet wounds. Disgusted
by this misinformation masquerading as facts, he finally wrote an
article for the Baltimore Sun.
Donahue was probably interviewed by a reporter of the Baltimore Sun.
bpete1969
2018-05-20 01:06:40 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Anthony Marsh
Which CYA do you think was the primary motivation for the cover-up?
Hosty not tracking down Oswald or the SS covering up an accidental shot
by one of its agents?
Provide proof for your claim that there was an accidental shot by an SS
agent.
Anthony Marsh
2018-05-21 14:57:34 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by bpete1969
Post by Anthony Marsh
Which CYA do you think was the primary motivation for the cover-up?
Hosty not tracking down Oswald or the SS covering up an accidental shot
by one of its agents?
Provide proof for your claim that there was an accidental shot by an SS
agent.
Excuse me? You are asking the wrong person. It is not MY claim.
Can't you sww that I was asking someone else about HIS theory?
Some WC defender makes that claim. Go yell at him.
I think his name rhymes with Clavicord.
Loading...